Title: An isolated you
sasaki_snake - February 4, 2008 12:24 PM (GMT)
If heart was made of stone
So cold there on its throne
Feelings are numb, would it succumb
It's resting all alone
If skin was made of ice
No possible disguise
Feelings are numb, would it succumb
So sad, but yet so nice
If eye was made of haze
A shattered, blurry maze
Feelings are numb, would it succumb
The loss of a happy gaze
An isolated you
By tables meant for two
Feelings are gone, there all alone
An isolated you
Refluxe - February 4, 2008 02:13 PM (GMT)
Eh, it just about withholds itself from so many general cliché's, so that's alright. You've got a few metaphors that borderline the lame, so I was close to yawning but didn't quite. I just pulled a fairly unimpressed face.
:mellow: <<--
The format works but it's nothing special. If you're having a repeating line for every stanza, it needs to be a tad more powerful. For some reason, I didn't like the whole 'succumb' jargon. Seems a tad standard just to whack something about feelings and succumbing. Oh the heartache.
Please avoid the use of 'nice' at all costs, not a wise choice of word...for anything, ever. 'Happy' and 'sad' aren't that great either, but they'll suffice in the context you used them.
Some of the rhyming words seem like they've just been thrown in there for convenience so it sometimes doesn't flow too well. 'haze' and 'maze' I wasn't too fond of. Whether your eye being made of 'haze' is a metaphor or not, it's ridiculous. I did not pull a happy gaze, no no.
:mellow: <<--
Last stanza had no impact on me, could have seen that coming really. Dunno, maybe I'm being over-critical now, can't really help myself. It's like you tried to stray away from the typical bullcrap like 'oh my my heart bleeds, I need to find the seed, from thy holy dove, the seed of love', but still retain that hint, that smell of typical bullcrap.
Needs less crap.
Oh I feel I should end on a positive comment otherwise I'm just cruel.
Good ...effort. Ah, can't do it properly, I'm a cock.
solidfox - February 4, 2008 04:17 PM (GMT)
Wow...wow...I choked on a piece of ice while reading Refluce's review...I should write some things just to get his review. That was the greatest thing ever.
Anyway, not much more for me to add, other then agreeing on the wording such as 'nice', 'happy', and so on.
JCC - February 10, 2008 08:18 PM (GMT)
Firstly, iambic pentameter sucks. It's okay though, because you failed at it numerous times anyway.
The heart is a TIRED old metaphor. Do something inventive. Go back to the old Elizabethan adage of thinking that love was in the liver rather than the heart. Do anything but witter on about the bloody heart.
| QUOTE |
| If heart was made of stone |
Yes?
| QUOTE |
| So cold there on its throne |
Is the throne a metaphor for the ribcage?
| QUOTE |
| Feelings are numb, would it succumb |
Depends, are these unique feelings that have nerve endings, therefore making the numbness possible?
| QUOTE |
| It's resting all alone |
Did the bladder not feel like coming out today?
| QUOTE |
| If skin was made of ice |
It would be like something out of Batman and Robin? That film sucked.
| QUOTE |
| No possible disguise |
Shitty rhyme.
| QUOTE |
| Feelings are numb, would it succumb |
Again, it would have to find some nerve endings for the feelings first.
| QUOTE |
| So sad, but yet so nice |
... Eh?
| QUOTE |
| If eye was made of haze |
What's the other made of, plasticine?
| QUOTE |
| A shattered, blurry maze |
How do you shatter a maze?
| QUOTE |
| Feelings are numb, would it succumb |
Nerve endings.
| QUOTE |
| The loss of a happy gaze |
It's made of haze anyway, so it wouldn't see anything. It is a non-functional eye.
:o Me?!
| QUOTE |
| By tables meant for two |
Poor tables must feel so cheated.
| QUOTE |
| Feelings are gone, there all alone |
Feelings have lost their entourages and bodyguards? Aw shucks.
Bleh.
Young Snake - February 15, 2008 03:27 PM (GMT)
Haha, man I've told you so many times, poetry is not your calling. Why don't you ever listen to me? :lol:
sasaki_snake - February 17, 2008 08:44 PM (GMT)
Thanks for all the beautiful feedback everyone. i'm not gonna give up, despite how much some of you might want it. i shall return soon with more poetic poetry.
The Black Devil Of Outer Heaven - February 20, 2008 02:42 PM (GMT)
| QUOTE (sasaki_snake @ Feb 17 2008, 02:44 PM) |
| Thanks for all the beautiful feedback everyone. i'm not gonna give up, despite how much some of you might want it. i shall return soon with more poetic poetry. |
Hopefully you do you evil....spammer...you!
It wasn't too bad so keep at it. Barely read it today. ^_^