I've seen this on another message board and its pretty cool. Its also a good way for all the talented graphics designers on here to show off their stuff.

Basically you just rate the signature of the person before you on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being excellent and 1 being absolute crap.

Rate this Ocelot one I just made.

8.9

Rate this one please.

[Just incase I change it; I'm posting it aswell]

9/10. Nice work.

9.5

i like it :thumb:

rate my new sig :D

cool man :P i like the green color


rating 8.8 :thumb:

9/10 :thumb:
rate mine!

thanks guys :D and i think yours is

9/10 iAn sig

viva la fox I would rate both of yours (the one you have now and the green one) a 9.5/10. Very nice.

What about this one I made with Solid Snake (the one from the "My Sig" thread I made)?

Thanks you guys. :thumb:

Viva la fox: 8/10. I really like that green in it, and that's a great picture of yoji Shinkawa's Gray Fox.
iAn: 8.5/10. Don't ask me why, but I really like it. It's nice and simple. The font you used is great.
RevolverOcelot19: 6/10. Snake and the MGS logo are a little too stretched. The blue backround's nice though.
RevolverOcelot19: 8.5/10. Your current one is great, and the filters and cropping are done very well.

heres another one. i didnt change much from the original screenshot though, becuase i did this one fast

and heres one i did as an experiment:

if anyone wants any of em, just say so. :P

Cool. 7/10 for the first. I like the font you used... Isn't that the Batman font? :yay:

As for the second, 8.5/10. That's really cool, I love your style. Is the other gun and forehead, Ocelot?

Okay, so this one I made for a guy named "Red Falcon." He loves Riddick.



Both of these are rather large one's that I'll never use unless I crop them down. :thumb:

- Watch. This one's animated.

nice ones L5! and yeah, thats Ocelot on the right.

for yours:
1st one: 9.5/10 instead of one color, maybe change the contrast or use 'color burn'

2nd one: 9.9/10 amazing! but a bit long ;)

Thunderbolt one: 9.4 i like what you did with the electricity!

Here's a quickie I made before bed, dont hate too much :P .



L5, in order:

7.4, 8.5, 9.1

Erm.....8? :huh:



Rate my sig.............it's the NGSF one...

What's the 'erm' about?

9 for the NGSF

Its the same sig with a different pic, so 9 again.

(try not to post just the score, maybe say why? If poss, thanks)

Solidus your sig has a 10/10 why.......



look at it :P its beatiful :wub: :wub: :wub: :wub:

yes indeed...who is that anyways?

I dunno how to say it but its jennifer something or other....

A high 9 because its animated. (Dont go off topic please, lol) Jennifer Ellison btw.

Aha, 12 because she's hot....lol.
:P

i rate it 9.9/10 because solidus really likes her :)

Solidus- 9.6/10.

Rate this one that I made for Dublo7.

8.9/10 for that sig

rate this one i made for dublo7 :D


and this sig but i wouldn't use it because it's a little bit too BIG :)

Aww... even S-S is on there, but I'm not. :(

Haha, nah. It's fine. :thumb:

Rate this one I made for Mr. Dublo7.

your not on there because it's all the members of NGSF Crew :)
and i am very sorry :( and i rate your sig 9/10 :P

rate mine


and this one too

viva la fox I would give both of yours a 8/10. Good work. They are simple, but at the same time they are very cool. Just keep practicing and playing around with effects and you'll get even better. :thumb:

here are some i made:

iAn... YES! :king:

Those two are awesome! 8/10 on the first, because I can't read the lettering. 9/10 on the Mantis toy one. :thumb:

All of these sigs look nice!! B)

Its hard to rate! :yay:

rate my sig please, its the first one i even made

It's very good I give it a 8/10! I like that name of yours and the trademark sign! LOL

thanks

Me likes. 8/10

I like the trademark and your O thingy, and i like the way the pics don't look like they're on seperate layers, which most do.

Psycho Mantis- 10/10. Great background, good pictures of Mantis, and the animated text. A total package.

Zero- 8/10. For your first sig ever it is excellent. It has a very clean look to it, and like Psycho said before the pics don't look like they are on separate layers which is a definite plus. Just keep practicing and playing around with effects and what not and you'll get even better :thumb:

thnx. the first one says:"I will fear...no EVIL"

Rate my signature at will. See if you can guess the movie it's from.

intresting. simple, but intresting
7.5/10